| Altona Properties Pty Ltd (APPL) operated a polyvinyl chloride
(PVC) manufacturing facility at its 16 ha (40 acre) site until February
2002. Until 1978, the PVC monomer vinyl chloride was manufactured
on-site from cracking 1,2-dichloroethane (EDC), which was manufactured
on the adjacent Dow site and supplied to APPL by an above-ground
pipeline. APPL’s manufacturing processes resulted in impacts
of EDC and its related tars to soil and groundwater on the site.
In fact, they resulted in a groundwater plume that extends some
500 m (1,650 feet) south of the site boundary.
This plume has posed a large problem for APPL for two primary reasons:
- It is prohibitively expensive to remediate all of the contamination,
which is bound in weathered basalts (clays) and basalt fractures
in soil and groundwater extending some 40 m (130 feet) below the
site surface and 500 m (1,650 feet) off-site.
- Remediation technologies used in similar situations have had
their own environmental impacts, such as the generation of greenhouse
gases, other gases that could include toxicants, and wastewater.
Related
Web Site:
|
As a result, APPL chose a general sustainable approach to the treatment
that was community-based, included source treatment and monitored
natural attenuation. PB’s role has been innovative in supporting
community consultation, providing complete electronic documentation
to meet EPA licence requirements, and managing a new technologies—
a special metal catalyst to remediate (destroy) chlorinated solvent
contaminants. Our effort involved careful planning and presentation
of information to stakeholders who required education and needed
to develop confidence in our ability to employ a new technology.
The Environmental Setting
The site generally comprises thin (0.5-m to 2-m, or 2-foot to 7-foot)
-thick layers of silty clay and fill surface material overlying
basalt to nominally 30 m to 50 m (100 feet to 165 feet) below ground
level (mBGL). Two aquifer intervals that may be hydraulically connected
(referred to in this article as the upper and lower basalt aquifers)
were identified in the basalt by previous works
1, 2.
Soil investigations indicated the extent of surface soil contamination
was confined primarily to the top 2 m (7 feet) of weathered basalt
and included free-phase product at the clay-basalt interface. Shallow
surface contamination was evident in the:
- Former tar storage area (south-west corner) in the form of
polyaromatic hydrocarbons, total petroleum hydrocarbons and monoaromatic
hydrocarbons
- Former EDC plant area in the form of EDC and VCHs.
These two areas are “hotspots,” or source zones, for
contamination of the subsurface and groundwater.
Electronic Documentation
Innovations in the project included the use of electronic
documentation to take the place of traditional paper-based
documentation. As an example, the Environment Improvement
Plan required as part of the EPA Waste Discharge License includes
an electronic Operations and Maintenance manual (EOM) and
Groundwater Management Plan (GWMP). The EOM is an interactive
HTML based application used by site operators and subcontractors.
The GWMP is a publicly accessible document available on a
web site (< http://www.altonagroundwater.info>);
it is used to publish details of public meetings, monitor
data and keep the public informed of on-going issues related
to the management of the remediation process.
Electronic file management allows easy updating and EOM reproduction
on CD avoids costs (both resource and time wise) and generation
of large amounts of paper waste. GWMP updates are made directly
to the web site. Both documents were designed and created,
and are being maintained by PB. |
Lessons Learned
- Choosing a sustainable solution that has community and
legislator backing can result in more modest resource requirements
for the project yet still achieves client aims.
- Developing a close and trusting relationship with the
client has been a key in achieving project goals.
- Examination of all technical solutions, even those not
tried and tested (stepping outside the comfort zone), is
needed to arrive at the “best suited” option.
|
Selecting the Approach to Contaminant
Treatment
APPL is involved in a number of community consultation groups concerned
with issues specific to the site and the Altona Chemical Complex
as a whole. As a result of the efforts of one such group, which
includes as members local residents, representatives from the Environment
Protection Authority (EPA), APPL management, neighbouring companies
and Hobsons Bay Council, a treatment strategy was adopted that called
for source zones to be identified on the site and for APPL to commit
to treating those zones. Source zones were defined as those with
highly raised concentrations of chlorinated solvents, probably indicative
of dense non-aqueous phase liquids (DNAPLs) in the vicinity. Source
zones were determined to include shallow basaltic clays, basalt
above standing water levels and groundwater.
It was recognised that technologies required for the treatment were
in development or unproven, and the heterogeneity of the site would
make uniform and complete treatment impractical. For these reasons,
the treatment strategy included the following steps:
- Treatment targets would be subject to further assessment of
what was practical and consideration given to the environmental
costs and benefits of continued operation.
- Groundwater outside the source zone would be treated by natural
attenuation and a monitoring programme would be implemented to
assess long-term plume trends and highlight any unexpected developments.
- Where possible, all wastes would be treated on-site and discharges
would be compliant with regulatory requirements.
Contaminant Treatment
The following methodology is being used to meet the above strategy:
- Chlorinated solvents are removed from groundwater and vadose
source zones by a combined air sparging/soil vapour extraction
system.
- Off-gas treatment is by catalytic oxidation followed by caustic
scrubbing of the hydrogen chloride generated by the oxidation
process. Catalytic oxidation at 450°C to 490°C (842°F
to 914°F) minimises the generation of polychlorinated dibenzo
dioxins (PCDDs) and polychlorinated dibenzo furans (PCDFs) that
may occur at higher temperatures (notably at 750°C to 900°C,
or 1,382°F to 1,652°F).
- Off-gas is emitted to the atmosphere under a Waste Discharge
License negotiated with the state EPA.
- Scrubber effluent containing sodium chloride is disposed to
the sewer under a Trade Waste Agreement.
More traditional remediation approaches including groundwater
extraction and carbon stripping of extracted vapours were assessed,
but discounted due to the large volumes of hazardous wastes they
produced. The use of catalytic oxidation (the technology itself
sourced from the U.S.) was the first such application in the remediation
of chlorinated solvents in Australia.
To date, a total in the order of 16 tonnes of chlorinated solvents
has been removed and treated from beneath the former Altona chemical
plant. This feat demonstrates the success of both the process and
technology in achieving environmental remediation. |
David Wenig is a senior hydrogeologist with
more that 8 years’ experience in contaminated land management.
He has extensive experience in project management, design, and implementation
of contaminated site investigations, groundwater monitoring programs,
site remediation projects, groundwater modelling, contaminant management
and health risk assessments. His involvement at the Altona site
since 1999 included management of the operation and maintenance
of the groundwater treatment system (GWTS).
David Adams is an EPA-accredited Environmental Auditor (Contaminated
Land). He has extensive experience in design and project management
of contaminated site investigation, human health and ecological
risk assessment and contaminated site remediation, especially of
organic contamination using vacuum extraction and bioremediation
techniques. Dr. Adams is PB’s technical manager for contaminated
land management. In this position he promotes excellence and technical
development of PB’s staff in this field, and he provides principal
technical review across PB’s work in this field nationally.
1 Natural attenuation of chlorinated
solvents in groundwater: principles and practices. Remediation Technologies
Development Forum, August 1997. Interstate Technology and Regulatory
Work Group and Industrial Members of the Remediation Technologies
Development Forum.
2 Technical protocol for evaluating
natural attenuation of chlorinated solvents in groundwater. Wiedemeier,
T.H., Swanson, M.A., Moutoux, D.E. and Gordon, E.K. November 1996,
Risk Management Research Laboratory, Office of Research and Development,
US EPA. Document ref. EPA/600/R-98/128.
|